Stick with the new one. Also you have to remove the cover to get the old one out anyways. Even with the rear mounts there is still a little play in the front one. Just mark it so it goes back the same. You are overthinking this.
Mark the bolt, remove the bolt and then lift the front of the engine just enough to get the cover off.
Mark the bolt, remove the bolt and then lift the front of the engine just enough to get the cover off.