Just an update.
Haven't had much time to work on this but tried again to start. Same issue. Only cranks with plugs out. Had more oil in the front cylinder so I have a decent seal leak. Will need to put a valve on the oil line.
I did however get the engine to crank just for a second with the plugs in. This was the first time I tried to start it in a week. After that, I couldn't get it to crank with the plugs in. Why would the engine crank for a second then no longer crank ever time I tried after the first time. Does this suggest a battery issue, where I don't have enough juice to crack the engine?
I also have a visibly corroded. Rear ebox ground wire where it attaches to the battery neg. would this ground cause an issue? I'll be checking all grounds this weekend.
I put a voltmeter on the battery when attempting to crank with plugs in. When I hold the start button, the volts drop from near 12 to about 7.5. This is when the starter isn't turning but trying to turn.
A battery that starts my 97 Gti 717 no problem isn't able to crank my 787 either.
Thanks for all the help!