Hey everybody, just got a 01 GTX with 951 engine with carbs. Right now its got 160 hours on it and is running pretty darn good. Looks to be very well taken care of. Just wanted to see some numbers on how many hours this engine will last before needing a rebuild. Also, the previous owner used the synthetic oil, and I purchased the seadoo synthetic oil. Is this really necessary for the carb engine? I heard it was for the DI engine, but not necessarily for the carb engine. Thanks.
Synthetic's of Group V status offer the best film strength protection of all the 2-stroke oils, not always necessary. Oils can break down and burn during the combustion process, the less they decompose during the process, the better the protect, IMO.
The 951 is a rave engine, and I think if you run a mineral based oil, like a good quality Group III, there is probably adequate film strength, however, the rave valve deposits may begin to reveal the difference, as the deposits may be abrasive carbon instead of the normal oily goo I've noticed on mine because the mineral oils probably decompose more rapidly than the esters, and it's generally understood they contain higher levels of impurities.
I think the phenomenon is pretty well explained on Belray's website:
http://www.belray.com/2-stroke-lubrication
Generally speaking, any 2 stroke engine that's not running and making power as it should, should be taken out of service and the problem addressed before engine damage occurs. Avoid running a 2 stroke engine if it is not performing well, some people keep running them hoping the problem will resolve itself but too often the "Italian Tune-up" approach ends up producing engine damage, regardless of which oil is in the fuel mix.
Perhaps it would be safe to say that if you only plan to putt around at half throttle and your boat runs correctly at all times, then the mineral oil probably has more than enough film strength to provide years of dependable service. I would still use a LOW ASH API-TC oil, I would not use TCW-3 or NO ASH oil.
I use the XPS II Synthetic in mine because I do get to WOT occasionally for short periods of time of probably less than 1 minute, and typically ride at better than 50% throttle, maybe closer to 65%.