Would be obvious. You would see the shadow where the gear was.
Measure it if you can just to see if its the same distance to the seals on each side and if so, your good.
So what happened to the gear on the rotary valve shaft ?
Did it just strip in one spot or did it chew everything up ?
When your in there make sure you rotate the rotary valve shaft and look for an up and down motion.
Usually when the gears strip it bend's the shaft and replacing just the gear will make it fail again really soon so just replace the shaft if its bent.