I use synthetic gear oil, 85-90wt, and grease all bearings and seal with synthetic grease. So, obviously the unusual noise was caused by bad bearings that allowed the impeller to woller around and tear up the new wear ring. A new wear ring should be a tight fit in the impeller housing, and screwing on the impeller, there should be a slight drag on the wear ring. A wear ring that is not a tight fit in the impeller housing, like some of these aftermarket type on eBay, can spin within the housing and makes that same noise. Best to inspect the wear ring before you remove it for uneven wear which could indicate bad bearings. And if you've got bad bearings, you've also got a bad seal