OK. Yes... if it was charged, and sat for a few weeks with the disconnect open... then I would say it's starting to give up. I thought you charged it... ran the boat, and at the end of the day, it was weak.
As far as the temp sender... sounds like it's right. I would say, 800 to 1K ohm is right. But it's a cheap sender if you just want to change it out. (around $35)