My Utopia was like that when I picked it up. Same story. The guy I got it from left it in salt water for a long time, and there were a lot of hard white build-up all over the bottom of the boat and the pump. It was a lot of work to clean those up. I tried several chemicals that claim to eat away marine growth, and I soaked the parts in saltaway overnight, and nothing worked well enough. I ended up scraping and sanding those things down and repainting the pump. I pulled the motor and the pump out of the boat to do this ( I rebuilt the motor too).
The biggest problem I had was getting those two plugs out by the inlet grate where you drain/fill the pump with oil (the one you use a flat head screwdriver to unscrew). I ended up stripping them both, drilling them out, and re-tapping them. I also rebuilt the pump with a pump rebuild kit (mostly gasket and seal replacements), and I rebuilt the wear ring with JBweld. I didnt like the performance after all these, so I replaced the wear ring and impeller.
If I had to do it again, I will get a used pump instead. For the time and money I put into reconditioning it, I would have been better off with a fairly used pump. I saw one on ebay where the guy was asking for 900 bucks or best offer.
I would definitely make sure that I can get those plugs out and be able to get all the parts out before ordering any parts.