Well, we've obviously got differing opinions of the anti rattle kit, I can see where you say you've sold 50 with no complaints and that the possibility of me having an underlying problem is the culprit to my continued rattle.
Wiith someone in sales, I wouldn't expect you to actually admit that the anti rattle kit wasn't all that it was cracked up to be. The intentions may have been to prevent it but reality, like everything else, didn't stop the problem.
Just to rectify my statement. I've had as many complain that when they purchased them, it also did them no good. I explained to them how to check their axial and radial movement to ensure they had no other issues.
Myself, I checked my pump and my radial play was less than .002" and my axial (end play) was .23. So, as you can see, my pump is fine.
The law of physics I believe applies here. It's obvious because, a thrust bearing is meant to bear a load. If there is no load on it, then it will rattle. That's why you don't hear it when the impeller is under a load.
In my expert opinion in actually using and evaluating this kit, I say your wasting your money!.........:cheers: Not trying to take sides But I do belive that Louis has a Very logical aproach to what he is saying as I have heard from many experts that this noise is very common with no load and it gives me comfort untill it fails. I hope to get a back up pump soon so that I will not loose a partial season due to a pump failure. :cheers: