The aftermarket carbon rings kind of suck. They work... but they don't live as long. The OEM carbon rings can last +10 years. But, the aftermarket boots are OK. Since the rubber boot is basically the spring for the seal... I recommend replacing it too. As long as the stainless ring isn't gouged... you can reuse it.
The plastic shaft protectors are just a stupid design from an engineer who probably never was in a boat. (lol) The idea is... if you suck up a rope... it won't wind around the shaft. The problem is... it will still get into the impeller, and then twist. In doing so... it will break the protector, and make it even harder to get out. Also... if there is any damage to the protector... it will cause cavitation. Because of that... any boat or ski I work on... I pull them out, and toss them in the trash !!!!